Monday, September 25, 2006

Anti-Porn Activists Want to Decide for Everyone Else

The following letter was published today in the Hampshire Daily Gazette. The author argues against Feminist Action Mobilization and NoPornNorthampton, in favor of personal choice. The letter is reprinted in its entirely by permission from the author.

To the Editor:

The town's Puritans are at it again, protesting the proposed Capital Video location in Northampton, using tired old arguments created out of whole cloth by the Christian Right, and without irony. The outlandish claim that adult films contribute to sexual violence has been refuted time and again by mainstream clinical psychiatry. Further, they demonstrate a fundamental misunderstanding of the role of women in the adult film industry. In fact, women are often paid more than and have a far longer "shelf life" than their male counterparts.

In a world where most sexual predators are not at Amazing Video but in the nuclear family, it is misleading to assingn blame for sexual violence on the adult entertainment industry.

But ultimately this is all beside the point. Any thinking person has trouble figuring out what is best for themselves in an increasingly complex and nuanced world. Every non-thinking person has no problem deciding what's best for everyone else. It seems clear what type of people these anti-sex activists are.

Nicholas Pell
Northampton

4 comments:

Anonymous said...

"The outlandish claim that adult films contribute to sexual violence has been refuted time and again by mainstream clinical psychiatry. Further, they demonstrate a fundamental misunderstanding of the role of women in the adult film industry. In fact, women are often paid more than and have a far longer 'shelf life' than their male counterparts."

Mr. Pell's irresponsible claims are made with no supporting evidence, and in fact are flatly contradicted by the documentation provided at NoPornNorthampton.org.

Anonymous said...

I find it interesting that authoritarians from Crawford, TX to Northampton use the phrase "irresponsible" to refer to opinions that they disapprove of.

In any event, here is a study regarding "pornography addiction", a malady not recognized at all by mainstream psychiatry which instead treats it as a form of obsessive-compulsive disorder. I also, in another article direct readers to Susan Faludi's Stiffed, an epic meditation on the post-war American male which includes their rather submissive role in the production of mainstream pornography, at least on camera. I would also direct readers to the writings of Annie Sprinkle and Nina Hartley, as well as any number of other works which do not support your findings and are far closer to mainstream psychiatric opinion than the works cited by your website.

-NP

Anonymous said...

Northampton Mayor Clare Higgins recently submitted to the city council
a zoning amendment that could force a proposed pornography store to move
outside the Northampton center. Some citizens are concerned about the
amendment's ramifications for the proposed new twink gallery
slated to open later this year.



Last summer Northampton residents Adam Cohen and Jendi Reiter created
No Porn Northampton, an organization trying to derail Capital Video's
Northampton store plans. The couple set up an activist Web site (www.nopornnorthampton.org)
to rally support. Feminist Action Mobilization is teaming up with No Porn Northampton,
which has gathered over 900 signatures on a petition against the store. Local women
started Feminist Action Mobilization this summer specifically to stop Capital
Video Cooperation from opening.

Anonymous said...

http://aff.pythonpays.com/gallhit.php?100236,159,8,2,0
http://aff.pythonpays.com/gallhit.php?100236,153,8,2,0
http://aff.pythonpays.com/gallhit.php?100236,148,8,2,0
http://aff.pythonpays.com/gallhit.php?100236,127,8,2,0
http://aff.pythonpays.com/gallhit.php?100236,126,8,2,0
http://aff.pythonpays.com/gallhit.php?100236,125,8,2,0
http://aff.pythonpays.com/gallhit.php?100236,117,8,2,0
http://aff.pythonpays.com/gallhit.php?100236,111,8,2,0
http://aff.pythonpays.com/gallhit.php?100236,109,8,2,0
http://aff.pythonpays.com/gallhit.php?100236,103,8,2,0
http://aff.pythonpays.com/gallhit.php?100236,102,8,2,0
http://aff.pythonpays.com/gallhit.php?100236,101,8,2,0